Sunday, December 31, 2017

MORTAL THOUGHTS 1991

Warning: Possible Spoiler Alert. Care has been taken to conceal as much as possible, but as this is a critical essay and not a review, some plot points are referenced for the purpose of analysis. 

“Come, you spirits that tend on mortal thoughts, unsex me here and fill me from the crown to the toe, top-full of direst cruelty!”    Lady Macbeth

Just as we know, with reasonable certainty, that Shakespeare didn’t have in mind two New Jersey hairstylists when he wrote Macbeth in 1606; it’s also an odds-on bet that said beauticians Cynthia Kellog (Demi Moore) and Joyce Urbanski (Glenne Headly), the morality-challenged friends at the center of Alan Rudolph’s skittish Mortal Thoughts, wouldn’t recognize a Shakespearean quote if it was set to music and sung by Billy Joel.

Yet Lady Macbeth’s impassioned plea to the gods to divest her of her feminine compassion and intensify her ruthlessness—the better to realize her homicidal musings—has within it the self-same dueling conflicts of violence/guilt/gender aggression/betrayal/loyalty/survival and desperation fueling the tinpot stratagems that set into motion the fatal events in this nifty ‘90s neo-noir. The castles of medieval Scotland may have nothing in common with the brownstones of 1990 New Jersey, but when it comes to survival, woe betide the woebegone male who dares underestimate what a woman is capable of when her thoughts turn to matters mortal.
Demi Moore as Cynthia Kellogg
Glenne Headly as Joyce Urbanski
Bruce Willis as James "Jimmy" Urbanski
Harvey Keitel as Detective John Woods
John Pankow as Arthur Kellogg 
Billie Neal as Detective Linda Nealon
Mortal Thoughts is an atmospheric suspenser of doggerel Shakespearean plotting and betrayals played out in the baseborn haven of Bayonne, New Jersey. Robert Altman protégé Alan Rudolph, who engagingly contemporized the tropes of film noir in his films Remember My Name and Trouble in Mind, again delves into the realm of the character-quirk crime thriller; this time having dark thoughts motivate the actions of a motley assortment of essentially non-thinking characters, all late-1980s time-piece artifacts depicted in finely-observed detail and only the most garish of local colors.

Mortal Thoughts evokes classic film noir in both the use of a narrative framing device recalling Mildred Pierce (a loutish man is found dead, a woman interrogated, a mystery unfolds via flashback), and in the cunning application of a crisscross murder threat redolent of the unarticulated alliance that got Hitchcock’s Strangers on a Train off on the right track (an amusement park even figures significantly in both films). But for all its shrewdly effective nods to the tropes of the genre, Mortal Thoughts, in training its lethal eye on the relationship of its two female protagonists, achieves—much like that other, significantly more popular 1991 release, Thelma & Louise—a kind of mordant unpredictability.
There’s a lot of tension and wit in the convincingly conveyed cronyism of Demi Moore and Glenne Headly (the latter, hands-down, this film’s MVP), making Mortal Thoughts feel like a welcome female-centric variation of all those macho “neighborhood buddies who go way back” crime thrillers of the sort beloved by Martin Scorsese and John Cassavetes (whose Mickey & Nicky this film recalls). 
"Your wedding was great. Except your husband...is such a...I don't know.
 I mean, what groom sells tools at his own wedding?"

Cynthia and Joyce have been friends since childhood. Each now married, they work at a beauty salon where, along with several pounds of permed hair and shoulder pads, they balance friendship, husbands, work, and children. 

Amiable opposites, Cynthia (Moore), the level-headed one, is married to Arthur (Pankow), a wheel-spinning go-getter type always on the hustle. Arthur is a kind and considerate spouse, but casually dismissive of Cynthia in that way common of fast-track husbands more in need of a “supportive wife” than an equal partner in life. One senses Arthur tolerates Cynthia more than he understands her, an observation driving home the equally strong impression that Cynthia’s always-in-tow children are where her chief familial priorities lie.

The emotionally volatile Joyce (Headly), has an obvious taste for Bad Boy types; explaining, but not excusing, her explosive marriage to James (Willis); a physically abusive, drug-dealing, macho hot-head. An accident waiting to happen, Joyce and James, who couldn’t even make it through their wedding day without a fight, are one of those couples for whom passion and erupt-at-any-moment violence are but interchangeable sides of the same dysfunctional coin. It’s in their marital DNA. So frequent and public are their contentious outbursts, the patrons of Joyce’s Clip ‘n’ Dye hair salon, situated just below the cluttered apartment Joyce and James share with their infant son, barely bat an eye when granted ringside seats to the duo’s regular-as-clockwork bouts. 
About now Joyce's thoughts are turning to ways of unsexing James with a pair of thinning shears

Events reach a crisis when Arthur, impatient with Cynthia’s de facto role as peacekeeper to the dysfunctional duo (and none too fond of the battling Urbanskis to begin with), begins pressuring his wife to stop spending so much time with her erratic girlfriend. Cynthia, feeling the stress of playing moderator, conciliator, and referee both at home and in the workplace, responds by doing more of what she already does far too much of: spreading herself thin trying to appease everyone.  Meanwhile, nobody seems to have taken notice that Joyce’s once easy-to-laugh-off threats to kill her husband appear to be graduating from thought to action.


Mortal Thoughts, in depicting the feminine side of all those urban buddy movies, does a good job of subtly drawing attention to the boys’ club network of protection that makes abused wives feel they have no options. Call the cops--they have no interest in punishing a man for what they see as “letting off steam”; appeal to the husband’s relatives--they see him as a good boy with a wife who provokes him; leave or get a divorce--invite stalking and jealous retribution.

The picture painted is bleak, but as many film noirs have illustrated in the past; a woman without power is not necessarily a woman without recourse.
“An accident, Dolores, can be an unhappy woman’s best friend.”  
Dolores Claiborne - 1995


WHAT I LOVE ABOUT THIS MOVIE
Mortal Thoughts lets us know from the outset that someone has been killed, but only by the 30-minute mark do we discover who it is (no big surprise there, nor do I suspect it’s supposed to be). The lengthy setup is devoted to establishing the characters, relationships, and setting (late-‘80s working-class New Jersey lovingly, painstakingly captured in all its cringe-inducing glory); the remaining body of the narrative devoted to unearthing the reverse-order specifics of the crime: the motive, the means, the when, and by whose hand.
In the book Flashbacks in Film: Memory & History, author Maureen Turim cites film noir flashbacks as being of two basic types: the confessional and the investigative. The confessional (as exemplified by the films Sunset Blvd. and Detour) has the lead character looking back over the chain of events which led them to their current (often dire) circumstances. The investigative (Laura, A Woman’s Face) has a law official piecing together the puzzle of a crime through means of examination and interrogation.
Mortal Thoughts employs both methods. In present-time, narrative flashbacks are triggered by the questions posed by two investigating detectives (Harvey Keitel and Billie Neal) to the fidgety, on-the-defensive Cynthia regarding the murder in question. 

Keitel’s Detective John Woods makes a big show of being the good listener just there to take down whatever Cynthia has to tell; but his piercing eyes (taking on a mischievous glint when one of his verbal snares yields prey) tell another story. He’s conducting a full-scale murder investigation without leaving his chair.  

With a video camera trained at her anxious face, Cynthia gives what can best be described as cathartically frank answers to their questions, these somewhat guarded responses delivered with a studied directness intended (one assumes) to convey an eagerness to unburden herself.
Unfortunately, Cynthia’s recollection of events, while superficially appropriate of an individual claiming innocence and who, as she puts it, “Didn’t do anything to need an attorney,” has a nagging habit of getting away from her. In attempting to provide the detectives with “just the facts” objectivity, Cynthia's subjective impulse to protect and/or conceal tends to result in her providing considerably more detail and backstory than necessary. Always volunteering a little more than she’s asked, Cynthia’s testimony takes on an involuntarily confessional tone, her account of the past frequently being at odds with what we’re shown.
Cynthia, distracted by troubling thoughts

THE STUFF OF FANTASY
It’s precisely when Mortal Thoughts tipped its hat to the unreliability of Cynthia as its narrator (especially since hers is the sole perspective we share) that the film really clicked for me. The doubt cast on the veracity of events depicted had the effect of shifting my focus from the story to the storyteller, at which point I found myself enjoying Mortal Thoughts not only as a mystery thriller, but as a sly dramatization of the threat of female alliance.

It’s telling that Mortal Thoughts is bookended by home movie footage depicting the friendship of Cynthia and Joyce from toddler to teens. These women grew up as sisters. They are closer to each other than they are to their husbands. At first glance it appears as though the film’s central conflict is the detrimental effect Joyce's toxic relationship with James on the marriage of Cynthia and Arthur; but one is reminded that nether woman is in a marriage they deem particularly satisfactory.

No, with the most intimate relationship in the film is the sisterhood friendship of Cynthia and Joyce. With this in mind, dramatic tension arises out of the film’s many subthemes: the inequity of marriage; macho as the flip side of male inadequacy; how women’s relationships are devalued by men and how easily women internalize and adopt these same attitudes—making the film’s central conflict the threat that female solidarity represents to the male.
“I fear for my life when the two of you sit down together.”  

For example: James and Arthur both have scenes where they vent their jealousy of how close Joyce and Cynthia are, each resentfully alluding to their wives prioritizing their friendship above their marriages. These scenes are echoed in additional sequences wherein the men are shown undermining the women's loyalties or encouraging one to betray the another (Cynthia’s rebuff of James’ crude sexual advances is met with “What are friends for?”), or trying to undermine the women’s loyalties.

For years men have benefited from pitting women against one another for the same reason the rich benefit from convincing the poor that other poor people of a different color are their barriers to The American Dream: there’s power in division. Misogyny is rooted in the male anxiety of the disposable (castrated) man, and many noir films exploit this fear. I mean, what is the noir femme fatale if not the embodiment of men’s terror of women operating under their own agency? Mortal Thoughts plays on society's limited, dual image of women, Cynthia behaving in the maternal, care-giving manner that reassures, Joyce (the breadwinner in her household) acting as feminine aggression personified. The trick up its sleeve is that it dares us to assume we know what’s really going on. 
“Everyone knows a woman is fragile and helpless. Everyone’s wrong.” 


THE STUFF OF DREAMS
A number of critics took issue with the brooding, almost operatic visual style of grand tragedy Mortal Thoughts applies (dramatic events play out with lots of slow-motion and choral accompaniment) to what is arguably a shabby homicide set in a garish world among unsophisticated people. But the film’s overemphasis on kitschy ‘80s details (and truly, you’d have to look far to find a wittier application of hair, costume, and production design) and magnification of the small lives feels intentional.

There’s nothing noble, high-born, or honorable about any of these characters. They are human in the most base, fundamental sense. But in Greek mythology when the Oracle of Delphi cryptically exhorts humans to “Think mortal thoughts,” this ethical maxim to be heedful of one’s human limitations reminds us how often it is in tragedy that characters pay a dear price for thinking they are above their mortality. In other words, acting like gods and believing they have the right to take a life or decide who lives.
That these larger-than-life themes play out in the small-scale environs of Hoboken, New Jersey, makes Mortal Thoughts one of the most intriguingly entertaining and off-beat neo noirs since Alan Rudolph’s Remember My Name.


PERFORMANCES
My fondness for the work of director Alan Rudolph is what initially drew me to Mortal Thoughts. But unlike most of his other features, Rudolph was not involved in either its writing or creation, having been brought in with only five days’ notice after original director Claude Kervin (who wrote the incredible and incredibly funny screenplay with William Reilly) was fired two weeks into production.
That being said, it’s difficult to know how different Mortal Thoughts would have been had Rudolph been involved from the start, for much of it plays out like a more coherent version of any number of his always-fascinating, albeit occasionally jumbled, character pieces.

For a director so skilled with actors and the intricacies of character, Rudolph’s has an impressive understanding and respect for the suspense thriller genre. He understands the importance of taking the time to establish atmosphere and mood, he knows how to build suspense, and (like Polanski at his best) he isn’t afraid of using humor even within the most intense scenes.  I like films with strong women protagonists and I like mysteries; so it’s no surprise that I found Mortal Thoughts to be a slick,  ceaselessly entertaining film with suspense, twists, and tension to spare. All bolstered by a uniformly excellent (and exceptionally well-used) cast.
Familiar face and frequent screen mobster Frank Vincent
(who died in 2017) appears as Dominic, Joyce's father

I’ve never been much of a Demi Moore fan and guiltily admit to never having seen her biggest hit Ghost (even after all this time I’m genuinely hard-pressed to think I’m missing anything), but she's absolutely terrific in this. My favorite performance of all (the few?) films of hers I've seen. I'm crazy about her in this. With her raspy voice (I even like her Joi-zee accent), sardonic wit, and sharp-eyed common sense, she’s like a real-life Wilma Flintstone. A pillar of rational-thinking against whom her not-wound-too-tight friend Joyce can bounce off of. And bounce she does.
As embodied by the late Glenne Headly (who passed away in June of 2017), Joyce is the quintessential Dangerous Woman. An outspoken trouble magnet, Joyce is a woman who knows how to take care of herself and get things taken care of; simultaneously the toughest and most vulnerable person in the film. Headly, a remarkably resourceful actress, is a marvel to watch from start to finish (not to mention listen to…her delivery and timing is priceless), and achieves the miracle of making her paradoxical character make absolute sense.
Bruce Willis and Demi Moore were still married when Mortal Thoughts was released, and while both were a bit off my radar at the time, I recall that they were a really annoying “power” couple in Hollywood. Both were riding high on recent successes: Moore exercising her clout by serving as producer on this film, Willis, hot off of two Die Hards (the flop of Hudson Hawk was waiting in the wings) was working off a lot of public ill-will (bad buzz from his offscreen Moonlighting behavior, a couple of ear-bleeder vanity records, and those cringe-worthy wine cooler commercials) by taking on a role in his wife’s film which played on what many thought of him anyway. It’s a film industry career ploy known as “Give the audience permission to hate you and they’ll get it out of their system.” A disliked celebrity takes on a self-deprecating or self-referential role and bingo, career clemency.
I can't vouch for those wine cooler commercial out of my system, but I do enjoy hating Bruce Willis in this.
Quick shout-out to personal fave and scene-stealer Harvey Keitel who does
wonders with his small role.  Never disappoints

Mortal Thoughts didn’t perform well at the boxoffice, but to me it’s an underrated, undiscovered gem. It’s a smart, well-acted crime thriller that not only delivers in the suspense category, but invites the repeat viewing to appreciate the rich characterizations, vivid production values, and sharp execution. Pardon the pun. 
Really, one of my favorites.


The film's first line of dialogue is also its last

Copyright © Ken Anderson

14 comments:

  1. Hi Ken,

    Wow, what could I have been doing in 1991 that this completely slipped off my radar? I vaguely remember coming across the title and thinking Demi Moore/interchangeable 90s erotic thriller: Jagged Edge, Fatal Attraction, Final Analysis, Basic Instinct, Animal Instincts, and probably Basic Jagged Attraction. Moore has always rubbed me the wrong way, but I’ve liked Willis in enough things,
    and Glenne Headly was definitely a plus in anything, so I’m off to Amazon rentals. (I can’t seem to find it anywhere else). Thanks for the heads up!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Max
      Those '90s erotic thriller titles got to be like film noir titles of the '40s: so similar you not only weren't sure if you'd seen the film before, but the titles began to parody themselves.
      This one really came and went from theaters very quickly and is rarely talked about today. Undeserved obscurity, in my opinion, but hope you have luck tracking it down!

      Delete
  2. Moore is very good when the writing and directing is very strong (Mortal Thoughts, A Few Good Men, Flawless) but she can't seem to elevate B-list material on her own (and who can?). Willis is much the same. Headly, however, is usually the best thing in any project she appears in. Any film that she's in in automatically worth seeing just for her. Bravo!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for mentioning "Flawless," that's one I've been meaning to see. I agree that Demi Moore can be good with good material. Something about her has a take it or leave it quality (which can be distancing), but this is one of those films where that quality works in her favor. Headly, gone to soon and with nothing like the career she deserved (although I've read, it's the kind of career she wanted: family came first) is always a fascinating actor. Thanks very much for reading!

      Delete
  3. Ken,

    Once again you've spotlighted an underrated gem that deserves to be re-seen. This is such a unique film - both for that era and also when measured against the other big-budget/high-profile fare that Moore and Willis were gravitating towards at that time. It's an unsung thriller, with a wonderful NJ atmosphere and a really solid lead perf by Headly (who's simultaneously funny, pitiable, and angry - a great combination).

    As background, Willis and Moore were widely perceived in the industry as behaving like enfants terribles back then. One of the co-writers of this film's screenplay (a television veteran but film newbie) was originally slated to direct this - after a couple of day's shooting, he was removed by Willis (who isn't even a lead here) simply because he was "untested" in movies, and I'm told the firing was done very gracelessly. Despite this, I have to say both Moore and Willis are much more scaled-down and believable here than they are in most any other film they've been a part of.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I missed the line in your piece where you touched on the public's antipathy towards parts of Willis's persona at that time. Yes to that as well!

      Delete
    2. Hello C
      You make a good point in citing how this small film was a departure for this high-profile couple who were indeed becoming more famous for their off-putting publicity. I too think the Jersey setting is very well-used and atmospheric, and that Headly is a
      joy to watch.
      And thanks for clearing up the circumstances surrounding the firing of Claude Kerven. When the film came out, there was a lot of press surrounding Rudolph taking over the reins virtually at the last minute, but all talk of the whys and wherefores of the actual axing came under the "creative differences" banner.
      Still, I think it's a great film for those who perhaps don't really care for either Willis or Moore. They definitely benefit from playing scaled down characters. Thanks so much for revisiting the site and reading this. Appreciate your knowledgeable info!

      Delete
  4. "With this in mind, dramatic tension arises out of the film’s many subthemes: the inequity of marriage; macho as the flip side of male inadequacy; how women’s relationships are devalued by men and how easily women internalize and adopt these same attitudes—making the film’s central conflict the threat that female solidarity represents to the male." Wow, that is some heavy s**t, Dr. Anderson. What a great post. I have never heard of this movie which really surprised me. I'm not a big a Demi fan but have seen alot of her movies, she was hard to miss back in the day (I loved Disclosure, talk about loving to hate her. I wasn't crazy about Flawless), and her and Bruce were never under the radar. I wonder why this one was such a big miss? Anyway, thanks for the great read, and yes, this one is easily available on amazon.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Before it all came crashing down I thought of Demi as the female Tom Cruise. And,"About Last Night" was one I really liked.

      Delete
    2. Hi Loulou
      Thanks! I'm happy you enjoyed this post. I like this movie a great deal, and find much to enjoy in its construction and themes; but I sense critics at the time mostly saw it as a mystery, and for some, the payoff wasn't worth the lengthy buildup. It is kind of strange how this film sort of dropped out of everyone's radar. It's no classic, but i found it so much more enjoyable than a many of her more high-profile roles.
      Given this was Moore's first job as producer, it seems there would have been a lot more attention paid. I know it was rather poorly marketed (the fate of many a unique motion picture that doesn't fit a set product). There was no sense given of what the film was about.
      I even think this was before Moore and Willis began wearing out their publicity welcome.
      Between Cybill Shepherd & Peter Bogdanovich/Barbra Streisand & Jon Peters/Demi Moore & Bruce Willis, there seems to be something about love and success in Hollywood bringing out the obnoxious in people.
      Sounds at least like you've seen more of Moore's films than I (never saw "About Last Night", so maybe this one will be up your alley. Certainly your description of her as the female Tom Cruise is pretty spot-on. Thanks a heap for reading and commenting so amusingly!

      Delete
  5. Read the first few paragraphs and stopped before I got too far and ruined it all for myself. I don't think I've seen this and now I have to. If I have I've utterly forgotten it. Thanks for this discovery. Added to my Netflix queue immediately!

    Headly had a much longer and interesting career on stage out here in Chicago. Lucky to have seen her in many a production before she -- like Malkovich (her first husband) and many of her Steppenwolf cohorts -- "went Hollywood."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. While it's never my intention to turn any of my film pieces into recommendations, I'm glad "Mortal Thoughts" comes with enough unfamiliarity/interest to make readers at least curious about it.
      I'd forgotten that Headly was once wed to John Malkovich, but I never knew she had an extensive and interesting career on stage in Chicago. Hollywood never quite knew how to peg her uniqueness, but mercifully, she did manage to land a few outstanding roles before being cast as moms. Whether watching this will be a discovery of a new film or re-discovery of a film you'd forgotten hope you enjoy it! Thanks for commenting, JF!

      Delete
  6. Hi Ken - indeed I do remember this "small" film made amidst Willis's and Moore's famed marriage and the string of box office blockbusters each made separately. Very entertaining film. And you are totally right, the gloriously quirky and talented Glenne Headly enjoys her juiciest role ever here...

    Last year, Paxton and Headly played the roles of the protagonist's parents in the disappointing dystopian film The Circle (based on a book I liked) and within months both of these wonderfully talented actors had passed on...
    Now I must see Mortal Thoughts again, it must be 20 years since I have seen it...and will watch it with your Shakespearean and film noir reframing in my mind!
    -Chris

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Chris!
      When stars marry and then marry their marriage to their screen personas (a la Liz & Dick) their onscreen pairings can be a lot more enjoyable than their tabloid exploits. I like Moore and Willis in this so much it makes me forget that I'm not very fond of either as Hollywood personalities.
      Thanks for bringing up THE CIRCLE, for that's a film I've been meaning to check out. I really hadn't known Bill Paxton and Glenne Headley were even in the cast. What a shocking gone-too-soon loss with those two!
      Thanks for reading this and commenting, Chris! Always a pleasure to hear from you!

      Delete