The "woman-in-peril" melodrama is a popular subgenre of film that fell neatly under the banner of the "woman’s
picture” of the ‘30s and ‘40s. Early films in this mold (Rebecca - 1940, Suspicion - 1941, Gaslight -1944) combined aspects of the horror film, film noir, and the romance
gothic in suspense narratives with female protagonists bedeviled by dashing and desirable men who, under normal circumstance, would be considered the romantic ideal.
In the postwar years, when Hollywood took to aggressively reinforcing more traditional gender roles, these sophisticated romantic dramas became decidedly more domestic in focus (Loretta Young in 1951s Cause for Alarm, Doris Day in 1956's Julie - the original "The stewardess is flying the plane!" thriller), and more conspicuously tailored to appeal to a female audience.
In the postwar years, when Hollywood took to aggressively reinforcing more traditional gender roles, these sophisticated romantic dramas became decidedly more domestic in focus (Loretta Young in 1951s Cause for Alarm, Doris Day in 1956's Julie - the original "The stewardess is flying the plane!" thriller), and more conspicuously tailored to appeal to a female audience.
The relative dowdiness of these black & white suburban
suspense thrillers eventually gave way to the tonier, full-color escapism of a the “posh women in peril” subgenre. Here, the aproned housewife of yore was replaced by the moneyed
lady of leisure, therein offering the added diversions of fashion show and travelogue to the mix as these well-turned-out heroines were photogenically menaced in delectably plush surroundings. To this latter category belongs producer Ross
Hunter’s Midnight Lace, an appealingly
glossy, routinely effective, thoroughly predictable woman-in-peril melodrama graced by a persuasively committed performance by Doris Day.
The Victim:
Doris Day as Katherine "Kit" Preston Overdressed + Overactive imagination = Patronized 24/7 |
Rex Harrison as Anthony Preston Neglectful husband with one too many last-minute "business" emergencies |
Myrna Loy as Aunt Bea Coleman Oversolicitous matron with a penchant for comic headwear |
John Gavin as Brian Younger Phone-happy, shell-shocked veteran with appalling British accent |
Roddy McDowall as Malcolm Stanley A Gen-X prototype. The entitled, ne'er-do-well son of the Preston's Dickensesque housemaid. |
Natasha Parry as Peggy Smartly-dressed neighbor with an absentee husband and a too-canny talent for always being at the right place at the right time |
Herbert Marshall as Charles Manning Avid gambler & worrywart possessed of the singular gift of looking guilty absolutely all of the time |
Anthony Dawson as Roy Silent skulker who might as well wear sandwich board reading "Suspicious Character" A Dial M for Murder (1954) alumnus |
John Williams as Inspector Byrnes Literally phoning in his identical performance from Hitchcock's Dial M for Murder (1954) |
Midnight Lace is the very last of Doris Day's regrettably infrequent forays into drama (a gifted and versatile dramatic actress, Day claimed to have put herself so emotionally through the wringer for this film that she vowed thereafter to appear in comedies. A woman of her word, Day saw of the '60s in a string of comedy films, her sole and final musical outing being in Billy Rose' Jumbo (1962). Midnight Lace, a high-toned hand-wringer about an American heiress in London who can't get anyone to believe she's being terrorized by threatening phone calls from an unseen assailant who's also making sundry attempts on her life, is a suspenser catering shamelessly to the Ladies Home Journal/Women’s Wear Daily crowd. At frequent intervals director David Miller (Sudden Fear -1952) and producer Ross Hunter (Portrait in Black - 1960) find it necessary to pad out events and throw mis-en-scène to the wind in an effort to play up the film's “feminine” distractions:
Thrill at the splendor of the ballet! Featuring excerpts from Giselle, Petrouchka, and Swan Lake! |
Gasp at the divoon frocks and bed jackets designed by wrested-out-of-retirement "Irene," who earned herself an Oscar nomination for her trouble |
Even Don Loper would swoon over the magnitude of marvy millinery on display! (Although I don't recall if any are in violet satin lined in fuschsia and purrrrple) |
Striking a note of violent hysteria even before the credits roll, Midnight Lace wastes no time getting underway, swiftly setting a wobbly foundation of emotional instability for Doris Day’s harried heroine to hurl herself from. As American heiress Katherine Preston, Day plays a newlywed “work widow”: a lonely London expatriate three months married to a British financier (Harrison) whose unforgiving work schedule leaves her with far too much free time. Too much time to roam the unfamiliar city alone; too much time to grapple with the confusing monetary exchange rates; and (as per the plot) too much time to fabricate phantom assailants in an effort to garner the attention of her neglectful husband.
Though the film makes us privy to the fact that she is indeed
the target of threatening phone calls and a series of near-fatal mishaps, Kit’s
nervous excitability, combined with a septet of vaguely suspicious supporting
characters, conspire to create just enough doubt as to whether Mrs. Preston is the victim or the agent of her torment.
When one settles down to watch a film like Midnight Lace—the motion picture
equivalent of those paperbacks you buy at drugstores and airport gift shops for
the sole purpose of reading poolside or on the beach—certain rules must be
applied: you either surrender yourself to its contrivance, artificiality, and slavish
adherence to form, or else you’re simply better off watching something else.
In movies like this, you buy into the fact that characters
never say anything directly when they can confuse and obfuscate with round-robin
statements like, “It was the man on the
phone! I saw him! I mean…I didn’t actually see him, but I KNOW it was him!” You allow for characters never alleviating another character's fear by announcing their arrival, letting their presence be known, or merely introducing themselves; no, they must wait until they are inches from the individual before speaking, or else they reach out and grab them on the shoulder before saying a word. You also must accept that all normal, rational responses to unsettling events will be met
by the suggestion to “Put it out of your
mind,” “Don’t give it another thought,”
or the laziest cliché of all, “Get some
sleep.”
But the necessity to check your brain at the door doesn’t
mean one can’t simultaneously marvel at the manner in which the entire plot of Midnight Lace hinges on and is propelled
by the Freudian fear (and subsequent dismissal) of the “hysterical woman,”
complete with its psychological tie-in to sexual frustration.
Midnight Lace was
adapted by two male screenwriters from the play Matilda Shouted Fire by British playwright Janet Green. Green was
co-writer of two of the UK’s most influential “social problem” films: Sapphire- 1959 (racism) and Victim -1961 (homosexuality).
I have no idea how closely the motion picture hews to the original
play, but I suspect the entire enterprise would clock in at roughly 23-minutes had
it dispensed with the presupposition that women are inherently emotional
creatures, strangers to logic, and prone to coming unglued under stress.
WHAT I LOVE ABOUT THIS FILM
In spite of its creaky sexual
politics, Midnight Lace is a surprisingly watchable little thriller that shares
a lot in common with another of my favorites, Elizabeth Taylor’s sole foray
into the suspense thriller genre, 1973s Night Watch. In both films a neglected wife’s claims of being terrorized are met
with both suspicion and disbelief by male characters. In each film the women
are driven to the brink of hysterical madness, suspected of fabricating an
emotional crisis out of a neurotic response to loneliness. The similarities in
plot and tone are intriguing, but the more contemporary feminine perspective of
Night Watch (another film adapted
from a play written by a woman) recognizes and incorporates the sexist tropes
of the woman-in-peril genre and subverts them to startling effect.
Like a great many genre films, Midnight Lace hews rather religiously to form, but thanks to its sleek production values and old-fashioned style, manages to
entertain even while offering few surprises as it wends its way to its
conclusion. A conclusion which took me very much by surprise when I first saw
this on late night TV as a kid, but which seems embarrassingly obvious to me
now. Midnight
Lace was released just a month after Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho, and as with that film, trailers for Midnight Lace encouraged patrons to see the film from the beginning and not to divulge to friends “the shocking surprise
ending!”
Myrna Loy, whose career spanned the silent era through to the 1980s, is a welcome presence |
PERFORMANCES
In the loony
disaster film Airport 1975 Karen
Black played a stewardess left to fly a commercial jet after the flight crew is
injured. The fact that Black played her absurd scenes with the utmost of
conviction drew both laughs and criticism at the time, but in a 2009 interview
the actress explained that her oft-parodied intensity was a result of having
seen the film’s rushes. It seems she noticed the cabin sequences were being played
for laughs or soap opera (Midnight Lace’s
Myrna Loy is present as a comic dipsomaniac) and none of the characters were reacting
to the impending danger of the plane crashing into the Utah mountains. Karen
Black’s acting choices for the cockpit scenes came down to “I realized that if
I didn’t care that the plane got over the mountain, no one in the audience
would.”
McDowall, Loy, and even Day had little good to say about working with Rex Harrison, his well-documented unpleasantness in this case perhaps attributable to the recent death of wife Kay Kendall |
Well, Doris
Day pulls off something similar in Midnight
Lace. Surrounded by a talented (if decaffeinated) cast giving earnest, stiff-upper-lip
performances (Harrison, Parry, Williams) or outright rotten ones (John Gavin),
Day being in a near-constant state of distress, panic, terror, and sobbing may come off
as shrill to some, but her 100% commitment to the material is the single element providing Midnight Lace with whatever thrill factor it has. In a plot bordering on the preposterous, Day makes the menace believable and her character's emotional disintegration compelling. Doris Day
is one of my all-time favorites, and though she's well-respected and beloved by many,
has never been given what I think is her due as an actress (WHEN is the Academy
going to give her an Honorary Oscar?)
In Midnight Lace, Doris Day’s natural delivery
and grounded, level-headed bearing works
miracles with the film’s artificial dialogue and contrived plotting. No matter what histrionics the script requires of her, Day's innate well-adjustedness prevents her character from appearing neurotic or unhinged. Indeed seeing such a healthy, uncomplicated screen persona crumble under pressure give her scenes of torment an unsettling authenticity. No pretty "movie star" screaming here. Day cries, wails, and lets out with guttural sobs that are positively heart-wrenching. The movie itself may be a tad overwrought, but I find nothing lacking in Doris Day's impeccable performance.
THE STUFF OF DREAMS
Midnight Lace is an
old-school Hollywood “movie” movie at its best. If you have a taste for such
things, these last-gasp studio-system entries before Hollywood shifted to
experimentation and naturalism can offer many amusing diversions. For instance,
I'm convinced the film was shot on a soundstage and backlot, it's that artificial-looking, but a few (second-unit?) shots look as though could actually be taking place in London.
Similarly, for a film of
this period, I was impressed with the color photography. At a time when flat, overlit
sets were the order of the day, Midnight
Lace’s cinematography (Russell Metty, Oscar winner for Spartacus) has a richness and depth that makes marvelous, atmospheric use
of shadows and color. It's one of those movies where everybody is always being offered a drink, women sleep in full makeup, and there is no such thing as dressing casually. And of course it’s difficult not to giggle every time a scene is
contrived to be filmed in longshot so as to better showcase one of Day’s many lovely,
matronly costumes.
These days I'm not really sure what condition the woman-in-peril film genre is in (my hunch is that TVs Lifetime Network pretty much wore it into the ground), but 1960s Midnight Lace stands as a high-style entry with plenty of retro appeal, and boasts Doris Day giving one of her best dramatic performances. Forget that it was originally targeted to female audiences, this Lace is one size fits all.
BONUS MATERIAL
Here Ms. Day models a leopard-print crowd-pleaser that never made it into the finished film. Watch the featurette (German soundtrack) HERE.
Copyright © Ken Anderson